MyCare - Patients: View your medical records securely online here.
Log in Learn More

Penn Fair Primary Care

Contact Information

Penn Fair Plaza
2200 Penfield Rd
Penfield, NY 14526

Phone: (585) 922-0060
Fax: (585) 385-0969

Map & Driving Directions

Office Hours

Monday - Friday: 8:00am - 6:00pm

About Penn Fair Primary Care

As a Rochester General Medical Group practice, we know that restoring the health of our patients and building collaborative referrer relationships go hand-in-hand. We are a family medicine practice, which sees patients of all ages, from newborns to adults. As a certified Patient Centered Medical Home (PCMH), our goal is to provide premier care to the community we serve. Our services include:

  • Routine physical exams and health screenings
  • Sick (acute care) visits
  • Medication prescriptions and refills (We require 72 hours notice for prescription refills. Please call your pharmacy and have them fax us your request.)
  • Immunization and flu shots
  • Minor procedures
  • Care Manager on site
  • MyChart online access to your medical records

We work closely with the Rochester region's top specialists at Rochester General Hospital to provide our patients with high quality medical care should you need care beyond your office visit with us.


To schedule an appointment, please call us at (585) 922-0060. Your cooperation in arriving on time for your appointment helps us stay on schedule. We offer same-day sick visits and appointments for patients with urgent problems.

New Patients

If you're a new patient with us, please arrive at least 15 minutes early to your first appointment to complete the necessary paperwork.


If you must cancel your appointment, we appreciate 24 hours cancellation notice. This allows us to offer the appointment to another patient seeking care.

What to Bring to Your Appointment

  • Your insurance card
  • A list of your current medications (with dosages), including any over-the-counter medications or supplements
  • Any questions you may have for your physician about health concerns, medications and treatment
  • Any prescription refills you may need so we can provide them for you at the time of your visit

Our Providers

Susan V AreeckalSusan Areeckal, MD

Although Dr. Areeckal is new to this area, she enjoys becoming involved in the communities where she lives, and looks forward to getting to know the Rochester area. While completing her residency in Kansas City, Kansas she often volunteered at community immunization / back-to-school clinics, as well as providing biannual sports physicals for high school athletes.

Dr. Areeckal has a keen interest in palliative care, and how it can complement curative, disease-directed medicine to improve the quality of life of both patients and their families.  In addition to English, Dr. Areeckal speaks and understands basic medical and conversational Spanish and Malayalam, a South Indian dialect from Kerala. Her hobbies include cooking, trying new foods, reading, writing, carpentry, sewing, and playing the piano. 


Dr. Yankey finds one of the most rewarding aspects of medicine to be getting to know and treating several members of the same family, at their various stages of life. She believes that her role is not simply to tell her patients what to do, but to listen closely to their concerns, to provide education, and to work together on solutions.

In her free time Dr. Yankey loves to spend time with her husband and three young children, as well as cooking, goofing off, reading, making time for personal fitness and missions work.


Fien_DougDoug Fien, FNP-C

Doug Fien graduated from St. John Fisher College in 2001 with a Masters degree in Nursing Science.  He is certified by the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners’ in Family Health. In addition to 13 years’ experience as a Nurse Practitioner, Doug has worked for 15 years as a Nurse in Community and Occupational health and served 6 years in the US Navy and Marine Corps as a Corpsman.


Meehan_Mary_NPMary Meehan, FNP-C

Mary Meehan, FNP-C graduated from SUNY Brockport with her BSN in 1995 and her Masters in Science of Nursing degree in 2002. She is certified by the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners in Family Health. She has returned to the Rochester area after practicing in Florida for 10 years in a rural health clinic where she specialized in pediatrics and young adults. She is interested in helping her patients achieve optimal health using integrative medicine.